News /

The Neobank Wake-Up Call Community Banks Need

When a community bank CEO is challenged by their own family to check out a neobank, they have to test the waters and open an account to see what the fuss is about — and within fifteen minutes, the CEO quietly closes their laptop and doesn’t talk about it again.

Low or no-fee ACH. Competitive wire pricing. Attractive money market rates on commercial deposits. A treasury management interface that doesn’t require re-authentication mid-session or a call to a support line to figure out how to update a payment file. All of it is available today, for a customer that opened its account without ever stepping inside a branch. How does a traditional bank compete?

This is the neobank wake-up call. And most community banks have been slow to respond.

What Defines a Neobank?

A neobank is a digital financial institution that operates entirely online, with no physical branch network. They are built on a modern technology infrastructure, which allows them to move faster, operate leaner, and deliver a user experience designed around how customers actually bank.

Most U.S. neobanks rely on FDIC-insured partner banks to provide deposit protection. They also offer speed, simplicity, and pricing that reflects a lower cost structure. That combination is proving highly attractive to consumers, especially small business owners, entrepreneurs, and the Millennial/Gen-Z individuals who have no legacy relationship with a local bank and no particular reason to seek one out.

The Customers You’re Losing Without Knowing It

As neobanks gain popularity, the most dangerous kind of attrition is the kind that happens in silence. A long-tenured business owner doesn’t call to complain about your $40 outgoing wire fee or the clunky ACH portal that looks like it was designed with the first wave of internet banking in the early 2000’s. They simply open a neobank account, route new transactions through it, and eventually stop thinking of your institution as their primary bank.

Community banks, for the most part, aren’t tracking this. They’re measuring the customers they have, not the ones quietly forming relationships elsewhere. New business formation — the entrepreneurs, freelancers, and small operators starting fresh without legacy banking relationships — is increasingly flowing to neobanks and fintech-backed platforms, where fast onboarding, digital-first tools, and low-friction experiences are setting the expectation from day one.

These aren’t limited to customers who left. They’re also customers who never arrived.

That’s the part that’s hard to see in a dashboard.

What Neobanks are Offering

Neobanks like Mercury, Chime, Varo, and Revolut are well-capitalized, well-designed banking platforms backed by FDIC-insured sponsor banks that have built their products around the banking experience. They offer:

  • Deposit rates that are highly competitive
  • Free or nominal ACH and wire transfers
  • Treasury management tools that are intuitive and require no training
  • Account opening completed in minutes, entirely online
  • A single, integrated interface with no third-party redirects or separate logins

The line between “fintech” and “bank” is narrowing and the institutional advantages community banks assumed were permanent are eroding faster than most are willing to admit.

The Wireless Industry Parallel

This pattern has a similar precedent. Twenty years ago, the major wireless carriers — Cingular, Verizon, AT&T — were trying to be everything to everyone. Smaller operators came in and said: we’re not going to do that. We’re going to own one demographic, one niche, and we’re going to own it completely.

The niche players had proven what was possible; the incumbents just needed to catch up. Community banks also need to catch up just like those large wireless carriers or continue to lose customers to neobank competitors.

Mercury, Brex, Relay — they’re proving that business banking customers want something different. The neobanks also hitting the limits of what sponsor-bank arrangements can sustain long-term, which is why they’re seeking charters. The question for community banks is if they will act now before these start-ups gain a larger market share.

The human barriers have not moved as much. And that is where the work is.

Banks that learn to match their technical ambition with genuine investment in culture and change management will not just get more out of each technology dollar. They will build an organizational capability that compounds over time — the ability to actually absorb change, rather than just purchase it.

When Staying the Course Becomes a Strategy

Community banks often point to their relationship model as the differentiator. And it is — for a certain customer. The longtime business owner who’s been with your institution for twenty years, who wants to call a person when something goes wrong, who values local presence: that relationship is real and it matters.

That customer is aging and expectations are changing. The business owner who’s starting a company today, who has never had to wait in a branch line, who considers a clunky payment portal a dealbreaker — they’re forming their banking habits right now.

The institutions most at risk are often the ones most comfortable with how things have always worked. They aren’t necessarily the weakest — they’re the ones that are not evaluating the neobank offerings and their customer’s preferences.

Is There Still Time to Respond?

Yes — but the window isn’t unlimited, and the response must be substantive.

The community banks that are getting this right are doing a few things differently:

Auditing client transaction history. There is a wealth of information in your client transaction history. Transaction data can reveal which competing institutions are receiving the client deposits and payments.

Listening to commercial customer feedback. Not through internal surveys — by sitting down with a business owner and watching them try to complete a wire transfer or set up ACH debit. The friction points become obvious immediately. Provide a way to customer communication to move from the front-line to the C-suite.

Rethinking fee structures on treasury management services. Non-interest income matters but charging $40 for an outgoing wire when competitors charge a fraction of that is a pricing structure worth re-examining today. And address incoming wire charges – even the loyal customer considers this unjustified.

Investing in the segment that’s actually at risk. Retail relationships have more inertia than commercial ones. Small business owners and new business formation are where neobanks are gaining the most ground, and those customers are looking for tools that reduce friction and free them to focus on running their companies. This segment needs a dedicated strategy.

Choosing technology partners that accelerate the roadmap. Building a better user experience doesn’t require building from scratch. The right core and fintech partnerships can close the gap quickly on product offerings. There are good tools available to compete effectively with the neobank model.

The Shift Is Already Underway

Consumers and small business owners are increasingly forming their primary banking relationships with digital-first platforms, and much of it happens quietly — well outside of traditional performance metrics and long before it shows up in deposit trends. The institutions that build a dedicated strategy now will be well positioned as the market continues to evolve.

Recent Articles